This Forum has been archivedVisit the new Forums
So this is an idea of how to organize our Armour and Weapons pages. I shall use "Glass" as an example. (Note: this does not include enchanted Armor or Weapons, it is the basic, unenchanted stuff you can buy in shops, nor does it include Raw Material, those will all have different pages).
So, instead of having "Glass Armor (Oblivion)" and "Glass Weapons (Oblivion)", I propose that the Armor and Weapons be merged into one page, though still be separated by which game they appeared in. So they would appear as "Glass Equipment (Oblivion)" (Note: "Equipment" is just the first name I thought of, it is not final and is open to change, if it is deemed necessary), instead of having two separate pages. I think it would be better this way, as the information about "Glass" would be all in one place, making it much easier to find, and will keep people from jumping back and forth from two pages. The other thing, is that as separate pages, the pages won't be very long, but by combining them, it'll actually look like a decent, informative page.
If you agree, simply state that, if you disagree (Note: If you do disagree, please state why, as in how you think the current set up is better), obviously state that too, and if you have a completely new idea, please share it with the rest of us. -- 'R BlaiddDdraigWolfDragon’s Lair 03:38, July 12, 2011 (UTC)
As I said on the IRC, I say it should be Glass Armor (Oblivion) and Glass Weapons (Oblivion). By having all the glass things on one page, it would make it too cluttered. There would be too many tables, and if we had separate pictures for each weapon and armor piece, it would just get to messy. Even if we had 1 picture for all the weapons and 1 for the armor, it would still be messy, what with all the descriptions of all this stuff on one page. However, having separate pages makes it less cluttered, and easier for people to quickly find what they're looking for..--With care and happiness, Supermutantslayer450' You will know the truth... And the truth will set you free.. 03:43, July 12, 2011 (UTC)
I agree with you 'R BlaiddDdraig.
I think it's stupid to have separate pages for Glass Armor and Glass Weapons. In fact, I think it's stupid to go from Smithing to Glass Smithing to Glass Armor or Weapons. Why not just have it go from Smithing to Glass Smithing that includes the tables for Armor and Weapons? It's not cluttered, and it prevents the individual smithing pages from being labeled as stubs. It's infinitely more efficient. ---- SenselessNoise (talk) 03:42, November 24, 2011 (UTC)